"As a professional software developer, I put the odds that the UK government will be able to pull off this enormous centralised IT scheme without scandal at about 0%. I have no confidence in the current governmentβs ability to resist the honeyed words of American tech giants"
Eight people react to Starmerβs digital ID proposal.
βA hackerβs dreamβ: Britons on Keir Starmerβs plan for digital ID cards | Identity cards | The Guardian
theguardian.com/politics/2025/β¦
βA hackerβs dreamβ: Britons on Keir Starmerβs plan for digital ID cards
Views range from concerns over civil liberties and cybersecurity, to welcoming it as a helpful system to streamline servicesAlfie Packham (The Guardian)
This entry was edited (2 months ago)
reshared this
Tofm2 π«π· πΊπ¦ πͺπΊ
in reply to JuneSim63 π • •JuneSim63 π
in reply to Tofm2 π«π· πΊπ¦ πͺπΊ • • •Yet.
Jonathan Schofield
in reply to JuneSim63 π • • •βin France in 1872, the government made a conscious decision not to collect certain kinds of data about people, including data about their religious affiliation,β Veliz said. βThe result was that the Nazis found and killed about 73 percent of the Jewish population in the Netherlands, and in France, 25 percent of the Jewish population were killed.β
mastodon.social/@urlyman/11177β¦
Jonathan Schofield (@urlyman@mastodon.social)
Jonathan Schofield (Mastodon)JuneSim63 π
in reply to Jonathan Schofield • • •This is my worry. I have Muslim friends and I already fear for them.
Jonathan Schofield
in reply to JuneSim63 π • • •indeed
@tofm2
Tofm2 π«π· πΊπ¦ πͺπΊ
in reply to JuneSim63 π • •Jonathan Schofield
in reply to Tofm2 π«π· πΊπ¦ πͺπΊ • • •@tofm2 my reason for referring to what happened under the Nazis is not to bring religion into it. Itβs to highlight what happens when data collected under a βbenignβ government becomes available to a subsequent malign government. Once you have an unambiguous signifier of who you are which you are mandated to carry, it becomes trivially easy for such a government to look up all the data they hold thatβs associated with that signifier. Hence Juneβs cautionary βYetβ
@junesim63
Chaotic Catboy
in reply to Tofm2 π«π· πΊπ¦ πͺπΊ • • •@tofm2 Ah, but did you guys try to collect Covid test results using an Excel spreadsheet template and lose 16000 positive results because it ran out of rows?
This is the level of competence we can probably expect here
π³οΈββ§οΈMichelle Laverick Music
in reply to JuneSim63 π • • •PointlessSpike
in reply to JuneSim63 π • • •JuneSim63 π
in reply to PointlessSpike • • •@PointlessSpike
It is exactly that, I fear.
democracyforsale.substack.com/β¦
Inside the Tony Blair Institute
Peter Geoghegan (Democracy for Sale)John_Loader
in reply to JuneSim63 π • • •JuneSim63 π
in reply to John_Loader • • •@John_Loader
Don't give them ideas! However, i suspect it will be Oracle.
democracyforsale.substack.com/β¦
Inside the Tony Blair Institute
Peter Geoghegan (Democracy for Sale)Mim54
in reply to JuneSim63 π • • •