TIL that Spotify ran ICE recruitment ads. Boycott Spotify!


The media in this post is not displayed to visitors. To view it, please go to the original post.

There are plenty of controversies surrounding Spotify, but what really made me cancel my subscription was the fact that they ran recruitment ads for ICE. Boycott Spotify!
#til
This entry was edited (Wednesday, November 11, 2026, 6:41 PM)
in reply to [object Object]

I tried it (Jan-March this year) and it's missing a large amount of music I like; I'm sitting on Apple Music since it seems to be the best balance of music availability, price, and privacy.

(inb4 'rip your own music and own it' since unless you're going to do it for me, it ain't happening; I did it early on, and unless you automate it from start to finish, it's a pain)

This entry was edited (Wednesday, November 11, 2026, 9:11 PM)
in reply to SurveyLance

FYI you can request your data too.

That's what I did after I left and put the money I saved into buying everything I'd ever listened to on Spotify as used CDs, month by month building my collection.

Im at about 80% ownership of what I was listening to after a year now and the test is mostly one off listens I don't want to buy anyway.

Wouldn't have been possible without the data dump.

in reply to wiccan2

I used Sunnify for Linux to convert my Spotify downloads to mp3 so now I have all the songs I listened to on Spotify.

sunnypatel.net/projects/sunnif…

  • Edit: looks like we gave the website the Lemmy hug of death. Here's the GitHub.

github.com/sunnypatell/sunnify…

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 7:45 PM)
in reply to SurveyLance

in reply to SurveyLance

ICE ads have also been ran on Meta platforms (Facebook, Instagram), Google platforms (Google Search, YouTube), Twitter, HBO Max, Apple, Amazon, Microsoft and Snapchat. Basically all of big tech that sell ads, with the notable exception of TikTok, which does not allow political and government advocacy ads.
This entry was edited (Wednesday, November 11, 2026, 7:38 PM)
in reply to warm

You can absolutely boycott them, unless you define boycott as being exposed, and not used.

I heard someone's phone play some music in passing in public yesterday. It might very well have been played using Spotify, which would mean that I "used" Spotify. This I, of course, disagree with.

This entry was edited (Wednesday, November 11, 2026, 8:56 PM)
in reply to Ekky

Yeah, but if you are using a site or service that relies on AWS or Google Cloud, then you are indirectly supporting them, as with more users the service will pay more to the providers.

But any amount of boycott is a great start and perhaps people and businesses will choose different hosting providers with awareness raised!

in reply to bitjunkie

Yes. I migrated my wife's Spotify to the Deez a couple of weeks ago and it was very easy. Over 1000 favorites and a ton of playlists. Only a few tracks weren't in their catalog, like maybe 10 or so.

Also note that if you are subscribed to some other persons playlist it will create it but obviously any further updates in the Spotify playlist won't sync to that anymore. They become your owned playlists in Deezer.

in reply to morto

I always select other and type in a minus sign or something. I am not doing unpaid labor of highlighting what's wrong with YOUR publicly traded for-profit corporation to help YOU earn more money by screwing us over. It's just not fair to help out a corporation for free that would never help out you for free, and would actually do all the agressive capitalist tactics in the book to extract more from you.

And that's if any of them even care to read this feedback, since they only care about shareholders' feedback nowadays, not UX. Otherwise we wouldn't have enshittification.

I am still happy to help out for free if it's a non-profit or privately owned company, and/or helpful, or a FOSS project. They deserve that stuff.

in reply to LavaPlanet

I don't know, sorry. But here is a list of alternatives:

TL;DR:

  1. Tidal
  2. ~~Apple Music~~
  3. Deezer
  4. ~~Amazon Music~~
  5. ~~Youtube Music~~
  6. Qobuz
  7. Soundcloud
  • Edited to cross off the alternatives that donated to Trump's inauguration
This entry was edited (Wednesday, November 11, 2026, 8:42 PM)
in reply to SurveyLance

Thanks! I use qobuz and have since the ai drone weaponry investing thing. There's so many other things too. I miss those neat info graphics with bad guys / alternatives for everything.

I really want to replace youtube next or at least figure out a fluid way to stream without adds. My grandson uses it and without it to calm him, here and there he can get a bit destructive / distressed.

in reply to SurveyLance

This happened quite some time ago.

AudiCable gives you the ability to download your Spotify library to your storage outside of the Spotify app. This will violate their ToS and they'll lock you out of your account until you contact support and tell them you won't do it again. I haven't tried this (yet) but I suspect you can download your Spotify library inside the app, turn off your internet, run AudiCable and transfer your library, then uninstall Spotify and they'll presumably never know.

... in Minecraft.

Qobuz is a outstanding music streaming service. If you're into EDM then check out Beatport.

This entry was edited (Wednesday, November 11, 2026, 9:37 PM)
in reply to ramenshaman

I used Sunnify for Linux to convert my downloaded Spotify songs to mp3. Now I have all of my songs locally. Then I deleted my account.

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 7:47 PM)
in reply to redkid1324

Help me understand. You're happy to boot lick Spotify for severely under paying artists (theft), with a CEO who openly supports war crimes (morally reprehensible) and happily runs ICE ads (also morally bankrupt) while praising Joe Rogan (need I say more) and yet you draw the line at someone ripping their mp3 collection?

The fuck outta here with that joke-ass troll shit. These takes are so pathetic there's no way it's a legit Lemmy user.

in reply to SurveyLance

There are FOSS alternatives.

I made a video about it.

in reply to Caves_of_steel

And Apple famously did never kiss trumps ass


Tim Apple famously kissing Trumps ass:


During a carefully choreographed White House visit this week, Apple CEO Tim Cook gave Donald Trump a bespoke plaque made of Gorilla Glass and mounted on a 24-karat gold base, but the real value may have been what Apple took home.

The gift, custom-designed by a former U.S. Marine turned Apple employee, featured a large circular slab of Corning-made Gorilla Glass with a hollowed Apple logo at its center. Trump’s name was etched near the top, while “Made in USA – 2025” was engraved at the base alongside Cook’s signature. The disc sat atop a solid gold base sourced from Utah, and even the packaging was produced domestically.

in reply to NuanceDemon

You do realise looking back at your behaviour should happen regardless of whether you are in the wrong or not, right? That's how you see if you unknowingly made a mistake or not.

Now, the fact that you immediately replied so defensively instead of looking back at your behaviour clearly shows you had no ability to do so in the first place. Thanks for proving my point, I guess?

in reply to NuanceDemon

You stand by the point that nobody understood? Literally, nobody here was arguing against your point, because we all couldn't understand it in the first place.

Did you already forget that you've already proven my point by immediately replying without trying to look back even a little? If what I did was weak, what does that say about you?

Not to mention that you actually used a more blatant "no u" as part of your argument before. Now you're just insulting yourself, for some reason.

This entry was edited (Friday, November 13, 2026, 4:59 AM)
in reply to redkid1324

I never did like him, but his blatant double standards made it kinda hard for everyone that didn’t have them as well.
in reply to redkid1324

That's a very weird thing to say

I have never understood what a "soy boy" is exactly

I've also never understood what white supremacists (I'm assuming you're some sort of bigoted weirdo) think they're achieving by pretending they have many children

I have no children. I don't like children

Right now, I'm laying back in my hot tub with a glass of wine

I can guarantee that all the things you would like to have, I enjoyed and then tossed aside

You're pathetic and you will die alone and lonely

in reply to redkid1324

lOok Up OpeRaTioN mOckiNgBirD

It's not the cold war anymore, troglodyte. Also, even if both sides do propaganda, it doesn't mean that you're not brainwashed by the Russian side of it. You do listen to Joe Rogan, so you're already a certified brainlet.

Try referring to something relevant next time lmao:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_Ten…

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 12:20 PM)
in reply to redkid1324

Not every song. Some artists offer their music for free and as a bottom feeder wage cuck myself, I'll take the bait. There are other times where artists have licensed out their music and literally can't sell some songs, and who they licensed to isn't selling it either, so torrenting IS the only option. In that case I usually try to pay more for music they DO sell, since I typically buy from bandcamp and they let you offer more money for music if you want to :3

I live in a capitalist country. Money is everything here, no matter how much I hate it. The arts are already incredibly undervalued by the same bastards who hoard the wealth If they live in a similar state to me, I want to make sure artists get paid for the passion they provide

in reply to SurveyLance

No ethical consumption under capitalism. If I boycott everything I disagree with, there's nothing left.

You're also assuming they have any other interest other than money. It's a capitalist business, all it cares about is money so of course they will give ad space to anyone they feel they can get away with.

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 6:35 AM)
in reply to Herbal Gamer

The media in this post is not displayed to visitors. To view it, please go to the original post.

also have used cracked apps for ages and don’t get ads if I can help it.

doesn't this count as voting with my wallet enough?


I don't know why you're so hung up on ads. The issue at hand is that Spotify assisted ICE for a year.


Or not, if ICE murdering citizens in the street doesn’t bother you that much.

So you hate waffles?

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 8:07 AM)
in reply to FistingEnthusiast

The way "no ethical consumption under capitalism" is meant to be used is to remind us that: 1, we shouldn't let perfection be the enemy of good (I.e. still boycott the worst people) and 2. that our long-term goal should still stay focused on replacing capitalism entirely. It is not meant to be used to condone abdicating our moral responsibilities entirely.

Participating in unavoidable harms because you need to survive is different from knowingly, willfully choosing the greater harm when you could opt out.

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 1:06 PM)
in reply to Herbal Gamer

in reply to SurveyLance

I understand not liking streaming and/or Spotify as a company. But people saying having a bunch of MP3's on a homeserver is in no way the same experience. At least not for me and a lot of people using Spotify I know.

Music I really like I collect on CD. Spotify is like snacking and for going on music safari's with related artists or playlists based on my interests. It's fast, easy, downloads are near instant and I can easy switch to my phone, laptop, car or speakers at work. At a lot of home parties Spotify is used to do a group playlist (yes, YouTube can do that too and every 30 minutes someone will wipe the playlist or add 1600 songs by accident..)

For everything there is a free and open solition but that takes dedication and sacrifice. Switched to Linux a while back, let a man have his vices ;)

in reply to HC4L

I've been using songup.tv/ at the office (usually just me and a few young people. It's a fun way to discover music and learn a bit about your coworkers). Not sure how well it holds up in larger settings.
in reply to HC4L

Honestly I don't even think off spotify (or any streaming algo for that matter) as a plus for discovering music. The algo will always steer you towards what it wants you to like. Or what it thinks you should like. Based on popularity and whatnot.

No, I do not want to listen to arch enemy's latest single when I'm clearly exploring underground lofi thrash metal.

I do not want to listen to run of the mill Deathcore when I'm listening to proggy deathmetal with blues influences.

I DO NOT EVER want to listen to Ed Sheeran when I'm supporting Macklemore.

Do the sacrifice of asking humans for music. It's much more rewarding in the long run. Not only are you genuinely going to find what you want. You also get to build and partake in community.

Something big tech is desperately trying to quell because god forbid you'd learn an opinion or two that they don't approve of.

You deserve better. And big tech doesn't deserve your time or clicks.

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 8:22 AM)
in reply to SurveyLance

A friend from a local band told me that the money they're making from streaming is maybe barely enough to cover the cost of being on the platform to begin with. So yeah, I can agree with "fuck Spotify" even before going to the sketchy stuff they've been funding and promoting.

I'm going the self hosting route myself. Navidrome running on a small PC at home, Symfonium on my phone, and music from Bandcamp and CDs I've bought. If you care about the artists you're listening to, you should care about supporting them. Buying a digital album on Bandcamp Friday for 10 bucks means 10 bucks going directly to the artist with no deductions. I haven't looked at the numbers, but you'd probably have to be streaming their stuff thousands of times before they make the same money from streaming.

in reply to schipelblorp

in reply to kamen

Well, currently I'm running via a mobile hot spot because I hate my cable company and I don't feel the need to send them money since my media is mostly physical and downloaded...

The other factor I'm a heavy mobile user and it's not unusual to run down the battery; taking the load off the phone battery with a separate, very efficient device, is a good move; and, not that I care particulary, but wired headphones with a DAC is gonna beat bluetooth on quality.

in reply to schipelblorp

Wired and a dedicated device will always be better of course if you can manage. I'm currently going with wired IEMs attached to a Bluetooth DAC/amp that connects to my phone. There might be some quality loss indeed, but I'm probably not going to notice it in the outside noise anyway. Still, I can use the DAC connected via USB too if I insist on lossless - but it's a bit cumbersome with using my phone attached to it. It's fine with a player that I toss in my pocket and maybe hit play/pause from time to time, but with a phone that I'm using way more often it's inconvenient.
in reply to green_goglin

Incorrect (Hulu / Disney doesn't own Spotify). Spotify is a publicly traded company and the top shareholders are the founders then institutional investors.

This is according to The Motley Fool, Investopedia, Kamil Franek, and Spotify's annual reports (which are their SEC fillings).

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 3:11 AM)
in reply to SurveyLance

Music streaming is amazing. I love it. It's so much easier to find new music.

That being said, best way to support the artists is to go to their shows, and buy their merch. Specifically, buy the album. There is no guarantee it will still be available for streaming forever, so best to have a physical copy and rip it to mp3 for archiving and digital use

in reply to SurveyLance

Working on it. Me and my family group tried PocketCasts + Tidal as a replacement, and while it kinda worked, it didn't work well enough to make it to a switchover. :<

We still want to switch, but we need to wait until some service does proper integration into as-sold sonos systems (Home Assistant is also an issue, but a solvable one). Tidal has it on their backlog, at least.

in reply to SurveyLance

Investing in Helsing is bad? What the fuck.

That said, I switched from Qobuz to Spotify when Qobuz fucked up the only Linux client out there. Spotify has easily the best Linux support of all the streaming services, and it has a pretty decent selection of audiobooks too.

This entry was edited (Thursday, November 12, 2026, 4:40 PM)
⇧