EU needs to make a stand on Play Integrity. If app devs enforce Play Integrity, this means only Google Certified devices can use banking, etc. This excludes all alternative mobile OS. No #postmarketOS, no #SailfishOS, no Android derivatives #GrapheneOS etc. You don't need Play Integrity. If someone is capable to install or use alternative OS, they sure know what to install or not install, it is on their responsibility. Using non-root but bootloader unlocked device (otherwise can't use alternative OS) does not make my device less secure. On the contrary, it is using an up to date OS with the latest security patches. Do we really want all mobile devices have to be Google Certified? No. #mobile #integrity #bootloader #unlocked #nonsense #Europe
This entry was edited (1 day ago)
like this
reshared this
Paolo Redaelli
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •Denzil Ferreira
in reply to Paolo Redaelli • • •@paoloredaelli I'm not sure I follow the reasoning behind EU wanting Play Integrity being a mandatory requirement for non Apple devices. Same way EU forced Apple to open their walled garden.
The only nuance thing here is, a Google Certified device means that they are running Google's proprietary blobs. So really, the course of action is, install alternative OS/use alternative OS and instead tell the devs of apps with Play Integrity checks that there are alternatives to check a device is not compromised - because that is what it should be about. Force Google to provide a different verification path that allows alternative ROMs/OS to be seen as safe.
Paolo Redaelli
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •Denzil Ferreira
in reply to Paolo Redaelli • • •@paoloredaelli we don't know what we don't know 😉 I trust we can elect EU representatives which share the same concerns. It is our responsibility to make sure of that if we want change. There are so many items that require attention, some more pressing than others. And we have the option of not using a smartphone at all 🙈 Banks are making their apps only work on such devices with Play Integrity, and closing bank offices. Soon, you can't check your balance, transfer, etc unless you have a smartphone that is certified (iPhone or Google Certified device).
Meanwhile, we can have an open dialog like we are having here, so that people around the world also think about what this actually means for them: no alternatives, no options, a monopoly.
ohir
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •> And we have the option of not using a smartphone at all
Not for long. At first you will not be able to pay for groceries. Finally not wearing a spying tag on you will immobilize you as a threat to the social order.
Technazis like sci-fi, just they don't like the endings.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Time
@paoloredaelli
In Time - Wikipedia
Contributors to Wikimedia projects (Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.)Gytis Repečka
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •How is Apple wallen garden opened?
They had (and still has) developer verification - same thing that Google is trying to introduce just now
@paoloredaelli
ohir
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •> EU needs ...
Do you realize that #technazi bros daily income is bigger than estimated life-earnings of the EU politicians of the past century, all of them?
Do we really expect EU politicians to resist this?
Tokyo Outsider (337ppm)
in reply to ohir • • •ohir
in reply to Tokyo Outsider (337ppm) • • •@tokyo_0
Actually I was saying about how cheap politicians have become comparing to the oligarchy class. Just one second of income of a top tier technazi is enough to "lobby" any member of the administrative and politician class. Yes there are people who can resist an argument to the sum of their yearly legal income but not many of them are in position to decide.
@denzilferreira
Johan Barelds 🇪🇺
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •@europarl_en @EUCommission @digitaleu
DFX4509B (Joshua Mason)
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • •- No desktops either if Google's QR captcha is any indication of where we're headed. Assuming this goes through, even desktops will be locked out of the web unless they're linked to a Google device by scanning the QR captcha with said device.
Or, Google could mandate AluminumOS to be able to pass their captcha on the desktop as well, and only through the Chrome browser.
Worst case, the end game will be thin clients tied to rented servers, which would ultimately be tied to your government ID.
like this
🍐 Perivi Yohanesburgo 🍐, destabilize enemy nations and Sam Lehman like this.
reshared this
Dirk Willrodt, Jacobo Da Riva Muñoz and Jon PENNYCOOK reshared this.
Denzil Ferreira
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •reshared this
Fruity Mercury reshared this.
keithzg
in reply to Denzil Ferreira • • •Yeah the irony of using a Google phone and being locked out of a lot of apps these days because now my phone is untrusted *because I've updated it to keep up with security updates* is very rich.
And any regulators sleeping on the incredible lock-in that results from this are basically just allowing oligopolies to solidify.