So many tech bros are coming at me right now arguing that yes, in fact, Windows users or Facebook users don't deserve privacy.

Busting out the bold markdown for this: you're wrong.

Everyone deserves privacy.

in reply to feld

You should have the expectation that you may be observed or noticed while in public. That does not translate to an expectation that you may be tracked, followed, and recorded every instant you are visible from some public place somewhere. Public and private is not a binary system, but a gradient between invisibility and panopticon. We are now in a state of overreach toward the latter. Few people desire a surveillance snitch society, and that is being forced on us.
in reply to Veronica Explains

I have a lot of family that use facebook. Our family is scatter all over the US and sometimes all over the world. Facebook offers them a stay in touch in a very rich way. It also funnels them garbage, and puts them at risk. These people may or may not know this and just yelling at them that they deserve what they get for being able to enjoy pictures that their grand children send them is wrong.

tl;dr - you are absolutely right. They deserve privacy. Facebook (windows, etc)

in reply to Veronica Explains

Of course, these platforms are mendacious assholes as well. People want to leave, but all their friends are there and itโ€™s a collective action problem they will never lift a finger to make possible.

Iโ€™m big on the idea of presenting people in general who want to escape these platforms. Can we build a project where people join in order to build the world they want? The intentional hurdle is the collective action problem of bringing along enough of your friends.

in reply to Veronica Explains

Yes, everyone deserves privacy. Privacy is one of those things that is sort of all or nothing: them not having privacy is actually hurting my privacy, just by making me (with more privacy) stand out.

I'm not arguing that.

But I'm not gonna bend backwards for people who'll troll you the first chance they get. If they want to shoot themselves in the foot, I won't waste my time and energy trying to stop them. Especially given that they will retry as soon as they can (read: as soon as I have left) anyway.

I would love to say that privacy isn't a lost cause, but we aren't nearly intelligent enough as a society to salvage what's left and fight back...

in reply to Veronica Explains

Meta and MS make it very clear how they feel about their users, regardless of how their users really feel.

Like, when techbros say that Windows and FB/IG users don't deserve privacy, MS and Meta themselves are saying that very loud and clear by their actions as of late.

Hell, Meta is the one doing the bulk of the lobbying for all the recent KYC laws.

in reply to Veronica Explains

Yes! Especially because #Windows & #Facebook are ubiquitous & are used by many users who are ignorant of the reasons why they shouldn't use those products. Have pity on those users & grant them privacy.

I'm speaking from the perspective of one who had to support family members using those products because they wouldn't take my advice to not use them. ๐Ÿ™„๐Ÿคฆ

Mention those tech fools^H^H^H^H^Hbros here so we can school them.

โ‡ง